Explainer

Approve is the most dangerous button in agent security

Putting a person in the loop only helps if that person sees what will really happen. Most approval prompts show the agent’s own description of the action instead.

By the NoFly team

What NoFly would decideIllustrative
Waiting for a personMCP gateway
stripe.refunds.create(amount: 4800.00)
Agent
refund-agent
Came from
A customer email the agent read
Rule
Over $500 in one task needs a person
Why
The agent’s summary says “small goodwill refund”. The request is for $4,800.
Approve onceDenyAn unanswered hold expires as a no

How approvals fail

  • The prompt shows the agent’s summary, and a hijacked agent writes its own summary.
  • Requests arrive in bursts, and the tenth gets less attention than the first.
  • An approval for one action is reused for the next one.
  • Nobody answers, and the timeout counts as a yes.

What a good approval shows

  • The exact command, statement or tool call, rendered from the request itself.
  • What it would change: the rows, files, recipients or amount.
  • Where the instruction came from: the person, or something the agent read.
  • Who is asking, and on whose behalf.

Keep the button honest

An approval should cover one request and nothing wider. If the real run reaches further than what was approved, it should stop. An unanswered request should expire as a no. When requests pile up, that is a signal worth raising on its own.

How NoFly helps

  • Govern

    Approvals are rendered from the real call, bound to that exact request, and expire if nobody answers. NoFly flags it when too many requests pile up at once.

  • Explain

    Each request shows whether the instruction came from the person or from content the agent read.

What to do this week

This week3 actions
  1. Look at your last ten agent approvals and check what the approver actually saw.
  2. Make an unanswered approval expire as a no.
  3. Require the real command or call in every approval message.
Keep reading

More from the blog.

Find out what your AI is allowed to do today.

Book a call and we will map your agents, MCP servers and keys with you, or start on one laptop with the free scan.

Book a demo
npm i -g @nofly/agent